Hello dear
Welcome to Bagigio's
Bagigio's, located at 8954 Woodville Hwy in Tallahassee, FL, is a charming pizza haven that delights diners with its warm atmosphere and delectable offerings. Customers rave about the excellent pizza, including the standout white pepperoni option and generous Stromboli. Many highlight the friendly service and inviting decor, making it a perfect spot for casual meals or special occasions. With a menu that also features scrumptious appetizers like Italian bruschetta and divine coconut gelato, Bagigio's has established itself as a local favorite. Whether you're dining in or grabbing a to-go meal, this restaurant promises a memorable culinary experience.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Cheesy Bread Served With Marinara Sauce
Water
BYO L
BYO GF
About
Bagigio's
Welcome to Bagigio's, a hidden gem located at 8954 Woodville Hwy in Tallahassee, Florida. This delightful eatery has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike, thanks to its warm atmosphere and mouthwatering offerings. As a food reviewer at Foodjoyy, I had the pleasure of exploring the culinary delights Bagigio's has to offer, and if I could sum it up in one word: exquisite.
Upon entering Bagigio's, you are greeted with an enthusiastic, "Hi, welcome to Bagigio's!" The inviting ambiance sets the stage for a truly enjoyable dining experience. The decor is charming, combining a modern aesthetic with inviting colors, making it a perfect spot for both casual meals and special occasions. Whether you're stopping in for a quick bite or celebrating a milestone, the atmosphere is both comfortable and sophisticated.
Now, let’s talk about the star of the show: the food. Bagigio's menu boasts an impressive selection of pizzas that leave a lasting impression. Customer reviews speak highly of their white pepperoni pizza, praised for its superb flavor, while the Americana pizza is known for satisfying even the heartiest of appetites. I couldn't help but admire the perfectly charred, soft, and springy crust — it’s what pizza dreams are made of. Additionally, the calzones have received rave reviews, delivering on both flavor and portion size.
The variety doesn’t stop there. For those looking to start their meal with something light and fresh, the Italian bruschetta bread is a must-try appetizer. After indulging in the savory dishes, I highly recommend treating yourself to the coconut gelato. Customers describe it as "divine," and I couldn't agree more. It serves as a perfect ending to a meal, offering a refreshing burst of flavor.
The attention to detail extends to their service, which has been consistently highlighted across countless reviews. Staff members are friendly and accommodating, ensuring that your experience is nothing short of excellent. There’s a noticeable commitment to cleanliness, with spotless restrooms enhancing the overall dining experience.
Some may mention that the prices skew higher, but when considering the quality of ingredients and the care taken in each dish, I found them to be quite reasonable. In this economy, where quality often comes at a premium, Bagigio's delivers an exceptional experience worth every penny.
In conclusion, Bagigio's is a wonderful addition to the Tallahassee culinary scene, perfect for casual family outings or a special night out. With its vibrant ambiance, delectable cuisine, and friendly service, I wholeheartedly recommend stopping by. You’ll leave not just with full bellies but also fond memories of a delightful dining experience. Come savor the magic at Bagigio's — your taste buds will thank you!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ 1st time trying this place and was verry glade we did. The food was great. The wattice was super nice. We had pizza and a Stromboli, which was huge! Will definitely be coming back. ”
“ The white pepperoni pizza is superb the Italian bruschetta bread is also a great appetizer, I had the coconut gelato (Devine) they had a movie playing I ate my pizza and watched a movie it was so great. This is the restaurant I wanted for my 35th bday dinner and it was to die for service was also very fast and kind. ”
“ You’ll hear, “HI, WELCOME TO BAGIGIO’S!” as you enter the door! You find your table, review the menu, then place your order with the cashier. They’ll bring it to you when it’s ready. The pizza is excellent and delicious! I got the Americana pizza and had more than enough for lunch and even needed a to-go box! When I was leaving the restaurant someone asked me how it was? I said great!! But their complaint was the pizza was small and a little pricey. In my opinion, in this economy everywhere is like that. However, for the quality of food that you are getting here the price is reasonable. In addition, the restaurant has a great environment. The staff is great and friendly! Restrooms are clean and nice! Come and try it yourself and leave a review. The food quality is excellent! Calzone is delicious I love it also. Check out the other reviews so you can have more details, they left great reviews as well and more excellent details. ”
“ What a nice pizza place! The decor is welcoming, and the whole restaurant including rest rooms were clean. Wonderful pizza, and great service. The 4 White Pizza was excellent, and the Pepperoni and Cheese reminded me of the old school stretchy cheese. The crust is slightly charred, soft, and springy with an authentic tasting dough. The Raspberry and Nutella Gelato was outstanding. We'll be back for sure! ”
“ Adorable little restaurant with tasty food. Great place to stop on the way to the shore from Tallahassee ”
“ Wife and I were trying to find somewhere to eat in Tallahassee. Ended up being graduation day we had to get out of all the traffic. Found this spot randomly and decided we’d give it a shot. Best pizza I’ve ever had! I wish we lived closer! ”
“ Literally our best decision this whole trip to come eat here! My husband and I were traveling for work and I happened to stumble across this place online and thought we should give it a try. We are traveling from Colorado (a place where we pride ourselves on making fresh homemade pizza with the best ingredients), and let me tell you..... this is the BEST PIZZA we have ever ate!! I have worked in the restaurant industry for nearly 10 years (managing pizza and Italian restaurants) and we have also had the pleasure of being friends with a lot of natives from Italy (so we have eaten a TON of Italian food). Pizza was not overly rich or greasy, flavors clean and fresh, paired well. We ordered 2 mediums, one Margaherita and the other White Pepperoni. Both excellent. And the homemade crust my husband ACTUALLY ate!! He normally never eats pizza crust. Also we had the Bruschetta (huge serving and their bread was excellent) and Strawberry gelato with Italian Chocolate on top, which were delicious as well! Staff is also very friendly and restaurant and bathrooms are very clean! The prices (for us being from Colorado) were amazing!! We literally dropped our jaws because back home that meal would have been insanely expensive for us! All in all, a must try! 10/10 would love to eat here again!! ”
“ First visit and it was fantastic! The food was phenomenal but the waitress was amazing. She gave great recommendations and was generally just the best. She helped turn a good night to a great night. If you haven't gone yet, don't wait! Hands down the best casual Italian in the area !!! ”